Executive Summary
Across 247 articles, our hit rate is 72.1% and our average signal return is 15.1%, so the overall record is still solid this run. Among the tiers with meaningful sample sizes, Sell is performing best on accuracy and average signal return, while Buy is the weakest this run; Strong Sell is mixed rather than a clean standout, given the smaller sample and lower accuracy than Sell.
This is one in a recurring series that reviews LF0 Research’s own past ratings against what actually happened to the stock. The goal is an honest scorecard, not a highlight reel — full methodology and every call we’ve ever made is at /research-performance/.
If You’d Followed Every Pick
Beyond individual calls, here’s the model portfolio question: what if you’d put $1 into every Buy/Strong Buy pick the day we published it, and a separate $1 short into every Sell/Strong Sell pick? We’ve rated stocks at very different times — some calls go back to June 2026, others were made last week — so each pick’s $1 only joins its book on its own publish date. The return below is pooled value versus total capital actually deployed at each point in time, not a return measured from one shared start date.
- Long book: -4.0% on 6 pick(s), $1 each. $6.00 deployed is worth $5.76 today.
- Short book: +15.3% on 80 pick(s), $1 each. $80.00 deployed is worth $92.21 today.
- Combined, long + short (i.e. every pick since we started): +13.9% on 86 pick(s), $1 each. $86.00 deployed is worth $97.97 today.
For comparison, here’s what the same $86.00 would have returned in a lump-sum buy-and-hold of the broad market since our first tracked pick (2026-06-09). This isn’t an identical methodology, since our capital went in gradually rather than all at once, but it’s the closest honest same-period reference point:
- S&P 500 (SPY): +3.2%. $86.00 would be worth $88.79 today.
- Nasdaq-100 (QQQ): -2.6%. $86.00 would be worth $83.79 today.
This Week’s Calls
BW — Sell (Notable mover — best active signal return)
What happened: We entered at $17.76 and the latest price is $4.86, for a stock return of -72.6%.
Why: Our Sell call held up because the core concern in the conclusion was that the valuation was already pricing in a recovery that had not yet shown up in cash generation. The stock’s sharp decline is consistent with that warning, and the debt maturity and weak EBITDA backdrop we highlighted did not need any extra assumptions to matter.
SMR — Strong Sell (Notable mover — best active signal return)
What we said: We said NuScale’s story depended on backlog conversion, funding needs, project execution, and whether the valuation was already pricing in too much success. We also framed cash burn, commercialization risk, and customer concentration as the key checks on the bull case.
What happened: We entered at $8.81 and the latest price is $4.82, for a stock return of -45.3%.
Why: Our Strong Sell thesis has been supported so far because the stock fell while the business still had to prove that commercialization could outrun cash burn. The original concern about valuation outrunning execution was the right one to focus on, even if the exact path remains tied to future contract and funding milestones.
CIFR — Sell (Notable mover — best active signal return)
What happened: We entered at $21.85 and the latest price is $7.15, for a stock return of -67.3%.
Why: The Sell call has worked because we argued the stock was already discounting a successful HPC ramp before the reported numbers showed stable, repeatable cash generation. The decline suggests that the market did not reward the premium multiple we thought was ahead of the business.
NLST — Sell (Notable mover — worst active signal return)
What we said: – Rated sell because the stock prices in cleaner cash conversion than Netlist has delivered.
- Strongest point: Q1 2026 revenue reached $104.9M, with EBITDA turning positive at $8.6M.
- Biggest risk: operating cash flow was -$15.5M TTM, so earnings are not yet self-funding.
- Valuation is rich at 5.3x EV/revenue and 48.7x EV/EBITDA.
- I would raise my rating if quarterly revenue stays above $100M and operating cash flow turns positive.
What happened: We entered at $2.44 and the latest price is $5.74, for a stock return of +135.2%.
Why: This call has been wrong so far because the market rewarded the revenue and EBITDA improvement faster than we expected. Our emphasis on negative operating cash flow and rich valuation did not stop the stock from rerating, so the timing of the cash-conversion concern was off even though the underlying issue still matters.
SDGR — Sell (Notable mover — worst active signal return)
What we said: – Rated sell valuation still prices in growth that cash flow has not earned.
- Strongest point: the platforms gross margin is 56.9% TTM.
- Biggest risk: operating cash flow is -$126.9M TTM.
- Valuation is rich at 3.9x EV/Revenue and 5.1x P/S.
- I would only improve the rating if free cash flow turns positive and revenue growth re-accelerates.
What happened: We entered at $17.40 and the latest price is $30.85, for a stock return of +77.3%.
Why: Our Sell thesis has not held up because the stock moved higher despite the cash burn we flagged. The market was willing to look through the negative operating cash flow and pay up for the platform, so our valuation caution was directionally right but too early.
LUNR — Strong Sell (Notable mover — worst active signal return)
What we said: – Rated strong sell growth is real, but cash burn and concentration risk still dominate.
- Revenue reached $203.4M in Q2 2026, yet TTM operating margin stayed at -18.1%.
- The key risk is customer concentration: 78.0% of 2025 revenue came from one customer.
- Valuation is rich at 6.4x EV/Revenue despite negative free cash flow.
- I would improve the rating only if quarterly revenue stays above $180M and EBITDA loss narrows materially.
What happened: We entered at $10.52 and the latest price is $13.03, for a stock return of +23.9%.
Why: This Strong Sell has been wrong so far because the market has continued to reward the revenue step-up even with the concentration and cash burn risks still in place. Our caution about the business model was not baseless, but the stock has shown that investors were willing to pay for growth before the margin and cash-flow proof arrived.
How Each Rating Did
Buy — 6 call(s)
Buy is only 6 calls deep, so we should not overread the 50% accuracy here. Even so, the tier is lagging this run, with CAR helping most and SM hurting most.
Hold — 161 call(s)
Hold remains the largest bucket and is close to flat on average stock return, which fits a tier meant to avoid forcing a directional call. PRU was the steadiest name, while EOSE moved the most and reminded us that a Hold can still be very wrong on volatility.
Sell — 58 call(s)
Sell is the strongest tier this run on both accuracy and average signal return, and the sample size is large enough to take that seriously. BW was the best performer for the tier, while NLST was the biggest drag.
Strong Sell — 22 call(s)
Strong Sell is more mixed than Sell, with 22 calls and a lower accuracy rate, so we should treat it as useful but not flawless. SMR was the standout winner for the tier, while LUNR was the weakest.
Sector Tilt
How the calls we’re actively tracking are distributed across sectors:
| Sector | Long | Short | Hold | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Technology | 0 | 25 | 30 | 55 |
| Industrials | 1 | 15 | 25 | 41 |
| Healthcare | 2 | 10 | 20 | 32 |
| Consumer Cyclical | 0 | 4 | 15 | 19 |
| Consumer Defensive | 0 | 1 | 17 | 18 |
| Basic Materials | 2 | 3 | 13 | 18 |
| Energy | 1 | 5 | 12 | 18 |
| Financial Services | 0 | 5 | 10 | 15 |
| Communication Services | 0 | 5 | 6 | 11 |
| Utilities | 0 | 3 | 6 | 9 |
| Real Estate | 0 | 2 | 4 | 6 |
| Unclassified | 0 | 2 | 3 | 5 |
Cumulative Signal Return
Lessons This Week
The common thread this week is that we were most reliable when we focused on whether cash generation and balance-sheet pressure could catch up to the story the market was already pricing in. Where we got hurt, the market was willing to pay for growth or a turnaround before the cash-flow proof arrived, so the next round of calls should stay especially disciplined about timing as well as direction.
Conclusion
Putting it all together: a $1 long book of every Buy/Strong Buy pick is at $0.96 (-4.0%) across 6 picks; and a $1 short book of every Sell/Strong Sell pick is at $1.15 (+15.3%) across 80 picks.
So far, the short book has outpaced the long book.
This is a running scorecard, not a finished one — both books will keep changing as more picks join and more tracking windows close. We’ll keep restating this comparison every week.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell securities. Ratings are tracked for 182 days from publication, then frozen as a permanent record.
Leave a Comment